GREENSBORO — “Life is a gift from God and we are stewards of our lives, not the owners.”
That was the message from Father Charles Vavonese, who spoke at a presentation on end-of-life decision-making and Catholic moral teaching at St. Pius X Church in Greensboro Jan. 15.
Father Vavonese serves as a chaplain with the Order of Malta in Syracuse, N.Y., and is the author of “I am the Resurrection of Life, A Resource for Catholic Moral Teaching on End-of-Life Issues.” His talk, sponsored by the Order of Malta of Central North Carolina, drew more than 100 parishioners from St. Pius X Parish, as well as local dames and knights of Malta.
Although “as Catholics we are not morally bound to prolong the dying process by using every medical means available,” Father Vavonese noted, “educating our population is critical for being able to give people the options to forgo physician-assisted suicide.”
We need to think, he said: “Are we prolonging the person’s death, or offering them life?”
Like other end-of-life experts in the Church, including the National Catholic Bioethics Center, Father Vavonese encouraged people to choose someone to be their health care proxy or exercise power of attorney, someone who knows what their wishes are and what the Catholic faith teaches.
“We need to find a way to communicate what our wishes are when we are unable to do that for ourselves,” he said.
Father Vavonese covered palliative care, Do Not Resuscitate orders, and what constitutes ordinary versus extraordinary care.
With extraordinary care, he said, we are not obligated to treatments offering no reasonable hope of benefit, or treatments that involve excessive hardship, especially when a patient is near death.
“We strive to give our families many, many gifts, and this one – the gift of making known our final wishes – is one of the most important,” said Debora Ritzel, parishioner and Dame of Malta since 2016.
“Even though end-of-life procedures can be quite complicated, the presentation was made in a way that didn’t seem threatening, that there are measures one can take which are clearly spelled out in the Catholic Church. And, even if one chooses the most difficult decision to be made, if that individual follows the best medical advice in conjunction with Catholic moral teaching, he or she should find comfort that they have honored both man and God,” said parishioner Tita Wofford.
“At a time when there are so many voices contrary to the Gospel of life, we thought it was important as Knights and Dames of Malta to invite Father Vavonese to speak to our community in defense of our faith – particularly as it relates to end-of-life issues,” said Monsignor Anthony Marcaccio, pastor. “Most of our people are totally unprepared for the decisions at the end of life.”
“We are people of hope with a firm faith in the promise of Christ and His resurrection,” he said. “We pray, think, talk and sing about heaven, but how many of us talk about that transition from this life to the next? When it comes to this subject or even the discussion of funeral preparations, denial is a powerful dynamic.”
He continued, “I learned from my own father’s death that one of the most loving gifts he could give us was a clear articulation of what he wanted going forward with his medical treatment. A clear, real, loving and Catholic conversation can ease the burden of responsibility that falls to the one you designate to direct your health care when and if you become incapacitated. A carefully written legal document may be helpful in knowing one’s desired course of medical care, but pales in comparison to having designated a compassionate individual whose conscience has been formed by our faith.”
“Given the advances in health care and the nuances involved in each person’s particular situation, it is critical to have our folks vest the legal, life respecting, decision-making power in a person, not in a document,” Monsignor Marcaccio emphasized. “For example, some of the same procedures classified as extraordinary care, may in different circumstances be viewed either as a temporary situation that leads to recovery or as an unnecessary burden that offers no hope of remedy. From my experience, both personally and pastorally, I beg people not to put off these frank and sometimes difficult conversations. I am so grateful to Father Vavonese for his presence and presenting us with a wide range of resources to start that very discussion.”
— Georgianna Penn, correspondent
Get more information
At www.ncbcenter.org: The National Catholic Bioethics Center’s website has much more information on end-of-life care and decision-making, including two documents Father Charles Vavonese recommended referencing, “The Ethical and Religious Directives for Health Care Services” and “Declaration on Euthanasia”
At www.catholicnewsherald.com: Plan end-of-life care and funeral arrangements with your family using the Catholic News Herald’s Catholic funeral planning guide